Tintin Movie - A Brazilian Perspective
Hey I have to thank Gabriel once again for this fine article where he has asked a few Brazilian fans to speculate and discuss the upcoming Tintin movie to be directed by Steven Spielberg. Oh and if you want to be a guest writer like Gabriel please click here.
Tintin and the secret of the Unicorn is one of the greatest Tintin adventures, no doubt about it. But is it the best choice from Herge’s Tintin albums to turn into the first Tintin movie?
In my opinion, Tintin in Tibet or Tintin and the Picaros would have impact on the media and audiences because they talk about actual
themes more so than Tintin and the Secret of the Unicorn. Now, talking about the 3D format and the real actors, do you think that Spielberg will be capable to keep the original comics characteristics even with the 3D and the real actors? Or maybe a movie with the same graphics of the cartoon would be better? Or the old cartoon graphics would make people that don’t know Tintin that well; think that is just a children’s cartoon? I wouldn’t like to be in Spielberg’s shoes right now, because this is a real big challenge!
Many questions that need to be answered fast, he’ll need to work very hard to please all Tintin fans around the world and try to keep the look and feel of the original Tintin albums. In my opinion he’ll try to change something so the story has more actual facets.
I asked some questions about these themes to some South Americans Tintin Fans:
Enéas: (owner of a Tintin community in a intercional relationship site) :
-Which Tintin adventure do you think would make the best movie and Why?
Answer: In my opinion, the choice of Tintin and the Secret of the Unicorn was very clever! The reason being that the locations are extraordinary, and this will lead to a great balance of adventure and suspense of which to entertain the audiences. I think that any other Tintin adventure would be very boring for the public in general. This movie won’t be watched only by fans, I think that the majority of people who will watch the movie won’t be Tintin fans.
-Do you think that even with the 3D format and the real actors, Spielberg will be capable to keep the original characteristics?
Answer: Herge’s own albums suggests a 3D format, you just need to observe the beauty of the Tintin culture and understand it will relate well to 3D. Anyway, the 3D will give a realistic aspect to the character without compromising the good old Tintin of Hergé.
-What Spielberg could do to add much more people to the Tintin fan club?
-Answer: Tintin is already ready! I think that he doesn’t need to do too much, maybe he could give a more actual character to Tintin for example turn Tintin into a sly guy sometimes, and change some parts of the history, putting in a few surprises for example…
Ulisses: (Brazilian fan)
-Which Tintin adventure do you think would make the best movie and Why?
Answer: I think that the best adventures would be “Tintin and the Picaros” and “Tintin and the Calculus Affair”, because the stories contain a lot of adventure and they also have a little bit of politics also! I also think that “Tintin and the Black Island” would make a great movie too!
-Do you think that even with the 3D format and the real actors, Spielberg will be capable to keep the original characteristics?
Answer: Never! Tintin is a 100% European cartoon, the opposite of the American style suggested for the movie. The 3D format is fantastic, with a big future! But Tintin and 3D just don’t match…
-What Spielberg could do to add much more people to the Tintin fan club?
Answer: Maybe add more fans wouldn’t be a good idea (remember of the “Lord of the Rings”) If the idea is to make more people like Tintin, It should be by the good and old comics. Good or not, the movie is just an adaptation.
Bianca (Brazilian Fan)
-Which Tintin adventure do you think would make the best movie? Why?
Answer: The secret of the Unicorn and the Red Rackham's Treasure were really good choices! But I think that Tintin and the Crab with the Golden Claws would be better, because the history shows the beginning of a beautiful friendship between Haddock and Tintin. Anyway Tintin and the Secret of the Unicorn will have a lot of attractions too, for example, Professor Calculus , Nestor(Haddock’s employee) and the purchase of the Moulinsart Castle. Some beautiful scenes could be done too, like the scene of Rackham’s and Sir Francis fight !
-Do you think that even with the 3D format and the real actors, Spielberg will be capable to keep the original characteristics?
Answer: I trust in Spielberg’s and Jackson’s competence. But we never know, they can do beautiful movies but they could also ruin the beauty and simplicity of the old Hergé comics. But in my view I don’t think it’s going to be difficult to transcribe Tintin to the 3D format. It might bring us a wonderful surprise!
-What Spielberg could do to add much more people to the Tintin fan club?
Answer: Excellent merchandising, showing a lot of adventure and suspense and of course the comedy that must be present in the movie!
In conclusion the new Tintin movie to be directed by Steven Spielberg is already proving divisive amongst Tintin fans with many fans unsure about Hollywood creating a movie from a European story whilst others believe in Spielberg’s story telling abilities. Still we have to wait for the actual film now scheduled for release late 2010. In the meantime the debate will not stop as loyal Tintin fans who are protective of their beloved Belgium boy detective discuss the speculate and argue about any Tintin movie to be made.
To visit Gabriel's Tintin Home Page for more of his work click here.
Tags: steven spielberg, tintin movie, tintin, peter jeackson, tintin and the secret of the unicorn